The 3 Rules of Living Animation


Originally published at:


I believe the Disney Imaginers call that kind of thing “plussing.” It’s part of the corporate culture there.


I liked the video but saying that the wya the animation in Mary Poppins is done breaks the illusion is a bit much. People, hyperbole is not necessary to sell your point.


A fantastic reminder of what a great film Roger Rabbit is, and why Richard Williams is one of the greatest animators of all time.


I was trying to sell someone on The Thief and the Cobbler a while ago, but couldn’t really suggest anything else he’d done aside from Who Framed Roger Rabbit. But then, perhaps there is no need to suggest anything else.


Thief & the Cobbler is tough. Individual bits are visual masterpieces, some of the most jaw-dropping animation ever put on screen, but as a movie, it’s honestly not that engaging. And your two choices are either the hacked-to-bits version on DVD or the “Recobbled Cut” which is like 1/3 test animation and storyboards.

Besides his TV commercials, probably the one thing besides Roger Rabbit worth watching is his version of A Christmas Carol, which looks like moving Victorian engravings.

I’m extremely curious to see the movie he’s working on now, which he says will be the culmination of everything he’s learned.


I found no hyperbole in that statement at all.

Even as a kid I couldn’t stand to watch them pretend to see the cartoons in Mary Poppins. When I saw Roger Rabbit I totally believed every second of it.


Fair enough.

Let’s agree, Who framed Roger Rabbit is a great movie, I loved it. I love the animation in Mary Poppins too maybe a little bit more. For reference, I was born in 77, perhaps that shaped my expectations for each movie?


I was born in 72 but didn’t see Mary Poppins until some time in the 80s.

On reflection, I think it’s just how flat the animation in Mary Poppins looks when put next to real people. I love the animation but they don’t seem to occupy the same world at all. Roger Rabbit characters actually seem to be in the same physical space.


This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.