Any sensible person then call the cops to say that there is an injured alligator that needs to be taken care off one way or the other. You don’t just leave it injured.
I remember a sign in a small park in Florida “Warning! Don’t play with the alligators”. I was’t exactly tempted, but it’s a very American thing to think you have to put up a warning sign.
Most likely the alligator went after someone’s pet and got a steak knife for its trouble. Alligator attacks on humans make the news, and I think someone would definitely mention the alligator making off with their knife.
Also, that’s a pretty impressive steak knife. The ones I have would snap before they even broke the skin.
I really hope there’s some Swamp Ahab missing a leg somewhere who’s the source of this knife…
Towards thee I roll, thou all-destroying but unconquering alligator; to the last I grapple with thee; from hell’s heart I stab at thee; for hate’s sake I spit my last breath at thee. Sink all coffins and all hearses to one common pool! and since neither can be mine, let me then tow to pieces, while still chasing thee, though tied to thee, thou damned alligator! Thus, I give up the steak knife!
I’m not saying your second scenario isn’t at all possible; there are, in fact, people who are just that abysmally stupid. Unfortunately.
But that immense stupidity still doesn’t give such a person any super-powers: no “super-stealth” to be able to creep up on a natural predator such as an alligator unnoticed, and no “super-strength” necessary to hold an alligator’s jaws shut with one hand.
Then there’s this; if someone is actually dumb enough to intentionally go attacking an alligator, a kitchen steak knife is probably one of the least effective weapons they could use.
Alligators seem quite peacful and sluggish when they are lying on the bank. They have been the apex predator since before the dinosaurs, and perhaps the don’t expect to be attacked. They also have relatively weak jaw-opening muscles, though the ones that close are tremendous: it is (allegedly) quite possible to hold an alligators mouth closed.
All these self-assured comments, and not even one person has considered the possibility that the gator might have stabbed himself. This is a cry for help, people!
If one happens to be a sadistic fuckwad looking for an animal to torture “for fun,” or whatever, there’s many far easier animals to go after, than a gator.
Ooh, the poor widdle 'gator. Someone stuck a knife in its eye, but you are hurting its FEELINGS.
No, really, there is a serious point here. The original post was fairly neutral: Someone stuck a knife in an alligator. We don’t know details. It seems unreasonable to jump from that to Someone stuck a knife in an alligator in self defence. We will not be able to solve this on BoingBoing, but there is at least a reasonable suspicion the person attacked the alligator. They had a large, if unsuitable knife when they met. There seems to be no local hero saying “I saved my friend from an alligator with a kitchen knife”.
If we are going to have empathise with animals, let’s do it properly. And not just for the cuddly ones.
When I was attending The University of Florida, the married housing and daycare were practically across the street from Lake Alice, home to several gators for many years. CYA, ya know.