Seems like she wasn't arrested so much for not returning the tapes as for ignoring the arrest warrant they sent to her. That frankly never ends well. The only problem I have is that the warrant was sent regular certified mail so there's no record that anyone ever actually received it. The courts presume it was delivered, but I don't know how many time I've gotten other people's mail because the letter was stuck in between pieces of my mail and the carrier didn't notice it. I've even had a lawsuit against someone else "served" on me where whoever "served" it stuck it between my screen door and the mail door and left. The law office was a bit put out when I called them and told them I had no clue who this person they were trying to sue was, they hadn't been at this address for at least the 7 years I'd lived there and probably longer since they weren't the person who lived there before me, and did they want to send someone to pick up their paperwork or should I just throw it in the trash? After all that, I can see someone not actually receiving a warrant if it was just mailed to them.