Lovely Trump / They Live mashup T-shirt

You’re confusing class for race here. They’re not “taking our jobs”, they’re making us work for them.

And no, it’s not a stand-in for “Jew bankers” and such Protocols-derived spew.

This is science-fiction as social commentary, not fearmongering and hate. I can’t speak for how Alex Jones and similar might interpret science fiction, but intention and execution does count.

4 Likes

I’m not confusing anything. It doesn’t matter if it’s class or race. All that matters is that they are an “other” working behind the scenes.

Frankly, I think you’re just bothered that this movie may actually be something other that what you thought it was.

Lovely Trump.

Of course, when you put on the glasses, Ivanka is a Hideous Alien Nightmare Creature, just like her dad.

2 Likes

Wow. After all that… I’m kinda on your side.
The movie is about a Grand Conspiracy, whether Rothschild, Illuminati, Jews or who/whatever.

As opposed to the more mundane fact that the Rich are just successful, sometimes morally dodgy, mere people.

1 Like

Well, it rather does if you’re calling it racist…

4 Likes

Thanks, man. I was fired up protecting an artist I respect. Thanks for being cool about it and welcoming me. I really do hope my message was not lost & people realize the truth about o’connell stealing the idea. I also hope you like Hefner’s art & they live inspired body of work. He’s funny and has some great stuff that zings the people that need to be zinged. I’m bummed that this guy knowingly copied his idea.

1 Like

Whether you consider the “other” to be a class or a race, in no way alters the nature of the film.

But it does alter whether it is “racist” as you so blithely declared.

2 Likes

The film was a reaction to the “greed is good” 1980s yuppie scum, it absolutely alters the nature of the film.

People are born in whatever bodies they live in. People are not born assholes, perhaps with the exception of the more sociopathic lizard-people. You can call it populist, classist, but if you consider class and race inseparable, no wonder you don’t grok the movie.

3 Likes

TBH there’s nothing stunningly unique about the idea of mashing up They Live with right-wing and neofascist politics (or even leftist, as Fairey was mentioned earlier.)

The extreme popularity of both sources guarantees that someone would come up with it independently.

1 Like

Not really. Exactly what is the difference, if the film is racist, or xenophobic? How is it fundamentally changed? The answer is, not at all.

That makes no sense whatsoever, frankly.

1 Like

It’s as if his critical analysis of the film is somehow the only possible reality in intention and execution, opinion fully devoid of the context of criticism through sci-fi of the time and counter-narratives to the yuppie movement.

I’m especially baffled by the assertion that all forms of otherness are the same while also distinguishing one in particular (racism) in relation to the film. I guess by that logic the film must also be sexist and homophobic, though…

Some people also believe that there’s a “gay mafia” pulling the strings, so it’s literally exactly about homophobia and ethics in gaming journalism.

1 Like

The film is a metaphor about the power of capital in the modern world… It’s bonkers to think it’s some how oppressing or targeting some group because it talks about that… The hidden power structures are a metaphor…

2 Likes

That’s just what they want you to think the movie’s about.

Who is this shadowy they? The aliens? The late Rowdy Roddy Piper? Zizek?

2 Likes

Those who engage in xenophobic paranoia don’t draw those distinctions. You’re looking at it from the rational viewpoint, and not from the viewpoint of someone who thinks there’s a crypto-cabal out to enslave us all…

This is a strange method of media criticism.

1 Like