Share your unpopular music opinions

I suppose my unpopular opinion is proving unpopular in the unpopular music opinions thread.

3 Likes

Wait, some people think of Taylor Swift as a feminist?

The hit parade hasn’t been worth a damn since minstrelsy fell out of fashion.

By which I mean David Lee Roth.

1 Like

To be fair, rather than being a thing that ā€œanother woman was putting out around the same timeā€ this is just one of th best albums of all time. It’s not like PJ Harvey could top it (except maybe her album of four track demos of songs from Rid of Me).

And speaking of Bjork and PJ Harvey, have you heard their cover of Satisfaction? I have it from Napster days and have no idea where it’s from but wow, they really can’t get no satisfaction.

Ha, when I read above that you think NIN might be good if he would stop singing, I was thinking, ā€œYou might like Fixed, thenā€

Also, with regard to your chart, I suppose I’m mostly level 3-4, but at what level is listening to radio static (an FM radio tuned off station) at maximum volume?

Sometimes woman-with-a-lot-of-money = feminist. (note that’s an assignment operator, not a comparison, depending on language, this might read woman-with-a-lot-of-money := feminist)

2 Likes

Maybe Mandela can share Mendeleevs, since so many seems to think it is Mendel’s anyhow,

They were/are great, but they aren’t heavy metal.

3 Likes

I hit every level of that scale. And if enjoying throat singing makes me unsuitable for public venues, I say bring it.

Pfft, they have math rock, but they don’t have math rap. Posers.

Eta

noise and free jazz in the same category, huh. I’ll put some ornette on one channel, Coltrane’s interstella space on the second, and some Justice Yeldham on the third.

Yeah we are gonna listen to all of them at the same time mutha fuppers!

2 Likes

Oh, I knew Jack hawking. He is metal.

(Joke… Strained beyond… Breaking point!!!..)

Interesting. That’s not something I ever really thought about her, based on the exposure I’ve had to her (my kids and wife are absolutely in love with her). A quick google reveals that she thinks of herself as a feminist, personally. Or rather, that she realized that feminism isn’t the ā€œBoo, all men suckā€ caricature that some people have in their heads, any way. I certainly never thought of her as a feminist artist, based on the (admittedly, many) songs of hers I’ve been exposed to.

Yes, because any woman perceived as strong is often read as feminist. Also what @anon50609448 said about women with money - they tend to be seen as empowered. Plus the fact that she’s not been defined by her relationship to a man, really.

[eta][quote=ā€œWearySky, post:392, topic:71708ā€]
Or rather, that she realized that feminism isn’t the ā€œBoo, all men suckā€ caricature that some people have in their heads, any way.
[/quote]

You would also understand it as her seeing the feminist label as working to her advantage, in that she can exploit it as a possible market for her music. Beyonce was riding the feminist wave, too and her success with marketing herself as a feminist might have become an influence on Swift. You could say that Gaga did the same with gay rights, too.

Also, Gaga isn’t that ground breaking or weird. Her music is pedestrian at best.

1 Like

By way, speaking of industrial/noise, am I the only one that can’t help thselves when it comes to pronouncing Einstürzende Neubauten it is always pronounced like the nihilists in big lebowski?

2 Likes

Isn’t she defined by her uncanny ability to have a kick ass career and bake delicious cupcakes?

(Or is that me? Am… Am I taylor swift!?)

1 Like

I hate Chicago more than I hate the fucking Eagles. But not more than I hate Steely Dan.

@TobinL: Good gravy, man, tell me you didn’t see that show in Iowa City? I saw the uncensored Freak Show a couple years later at the Majestic in Detroit.

1 Like

You’re totally a Taylor Swift. I’m more of a… I dunno, Diamanda Galas, without the talent? :wink:

2 Likes

Certainly any one of us can scream incoherently, no?

(Perhaps she has less irritating recordings, but after being exposed to the screaming, I ran away without looking back.)

1 Like

Ever heard her version of Gloomy Sunday? Second only to Billie Holiday:

St.Louis…, in 1995 at what is now the Scott Trade Center. It is a big venue.

1 Like

That’s OK. I think I’m right off the chart. I mean, where do Schoenberg, Dallapiccola and a passel of obscure Soviet composers fit in that chart? Or Cabezón or Dr. Bull, for that matter? (Or maybe even Third Stream with a distinct Balkans flavour, like my friend Samir Fejzic in Sarajevo.)

<sigh> We lost Ornette Coleman and Gunther Schuller last year, Paul Bley just a few days ago. The Mighty are dropping like flies.

1 Like

I knew someone who worked tech on one of her shows. Said she was an incredible pain to work with.

Another compelling reason for nominating Lemmy is that there are, to my knowledge, few single words in the heavy metal lexicon that (1) roll off the tongue when modified to adopt the appending ā€˜-ium’, (2) retain their original intonation and vowel articulation when appended such, and (3) signify a watermark in heavy metal history.

Mastodon --> Mastodonium [(2) not met, too soon to grant them (3)]
Ozzy --> Ozzium [disqualified due to similarity in sound to osmium and not being Lemmy]
Lombardo --> Lombardium [effectively disqualified because drummers never get enough respect]
Patton --> Pattonium [debatable, as Patton has his hands in way more honey jars than just metal; also, a bit too close in sound to plutonium]
Gwar --> Gwarium [no]

Lemmium meets all criteria, plus it actually sounds like the name of an element.

2 Likes