Video of comedian "punched" after racist routine goes viral again

Originally published at:

I’ve heard Roy Chubby Brown make similar excuses. I don’t believe him.


Everything about this video is depressing.


If the video is staged (which it most likely is) it’s just unfunny, far from clever, lazy, and offensive in all the worst ways a comedian can be. I don’t mind a comedian being offensive and pushing the boundaries of what the audience will laugh at, but this is just a poor excuse of a bit. Fuck this guy.


Ugh, what a moran. Why is this bit of shite coming back to haunt us again?


[quote]The clip is Eidman’s only real fame[/quote]What more need be said?


I am so tired of these idiots not understanding that we get that it’s a joke, it’s just that we don’t care because being racist while being funny (let’s pretend for a moment that there was funny here) is still fucking well being racist.


Right, this kind of crap has been going on for a looooong time.

Oldie but goodie:


I am so glad I have this little voice that sometimes whispers, “no, that joke is not funny. STFU.” I usually listen. Not always, but I’m getting better.


Erin Moran would not have appreciated that.


Counter this with Stephen Colbert doing his mock-Asian shtick on “The Colbert Report” – in those bits he was mocking people like Eidman: he’s not portraying a stereotype of an Asian, he portraying a stereotype of a right-wing douche portraying an Asian.

Is that better? I don’t know. I always gave it a pass, even though it made me cringe a bit.

1 Like

Or Caitlin Moran (for the more UK-centric Moran spotter)


Get a brain, morans, it’s a joke!

(Not that I can tell whether or not you know that. My apologies to all Morans.)


No, it’s not a joke!

(It’s a meme.)

I don’t think he should have been given a pass. Ironic racism that trots out old stereotypes nevertheless promulgates those stereotypes. His staff apologized, and I agreed with those who said they should have done so.


joke. typo. joke. typo.


. . . for only one incident, a tweet, whereas he did it multiple times over the course of the show, as noted in the link:

To note: “Ching Chong Ding Dong” has been a Colbert Report staple since the show’s launch in 2005, and is a fairly meta bit wherein Stephen Colbert’s pundit character pretends to be anothercharacter (a bucktoothed Chinaman stereotype), and sees nothing wrong with it because “there’s a difference between me and a character I’m doing.”

And then there’s the incident with Michael Richards at The Laugh Factory.


The quotes in the title should be around “comedian”, not “punched”.


I think one of the important takeaways here is that there often is absolutely no need for racism to make many funny bits work.
My case in point would be comedian Bill Dana, who used to do the character of José Jiménez on the Steve Allen show in the 50s/60s. After a few years of doing this character (and after public protests by Hispanics), Mr. Dana appeared to have grown a conscience, and later made a public apology at a cultural pride festival.

The thing is, the bits work great without the racism! There was never any need for it.
You simply have a character playing the fool - and I don’t even mean mentally challenged - and it works.

Ed Sullivan: "Well, now I see you have some of your space equipment with you. Uh, what is that called, the crash helmet?"
José Jiménez (as an astronaut): “Oh, I hope not.”

Ed Sullivan: "Now, what do you consider the most important thing in rocket travel?"
José Jiménez: "To me the most important thing in the rocket travel is the blast-off."
Ed Sullivan: "The blast-off."
José Jiménez: “I always take a blast before I take off. Otherwise I wouldn’t go near that thing.”